Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wpdb::$categories is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\wp-db.php on line 760

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wpdb::$post2cat is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\wp-db.php on line 760

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property wpdb::$link2cat is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\wp-db.php on line 760

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Main::$helpers is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\lib\abstract-main.php on line 65

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Block_Type::$skip_inner_blocks is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type.php on line 357

Deprecated: Constant FILTER_SANITIZE_STRING is deprecated since 8.1, use htmlspecialchars() instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\conditionals\third-party\elementor-edit-conditional.php on line 22

Deprecated: Constant FILTER_SANITIZE_STRING is deprecated since 8.1, use htmlspecialchars() instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\conditionals\third-party\elementor-edit-conditional.php on line 28
<br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Surfaces\Classes_Surface::$container is deprecated in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\surfaces\classes-surface.php</b> on line <b>20</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Main::$classes is deprecated in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\lib\abstract-main.php</b> on line <b>65</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\helpers\blocks-helper.php</b> on line <b>84</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\helpers\blocks-helper.php</b> on line <b>85</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\helpers\blocks-helper.php</b> on line <b>87</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$page_type is deprecated in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php</b> on line <b>43</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$title is deprecated in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php</b> on line <b>64</b><br /> <br /> <b>Deprecated</b>: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$source is deprecated in <b>D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php</b> on line <b>64</b><br /> Save Mart Supermarkets v. Orchard Supply Hardware - MAMMOTH ADVISORS, INC.
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$robots is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$meta_description is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$canonical is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$rel_prev is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$rel_next is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_locale is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_type is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_title is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_description is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_url is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$wordpress_site_name is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_site_name is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$company_name is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$site_represents is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$open_graph_publisher is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_article_publisher is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_article_author is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_article_published_time is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_article_modified_time is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$open_graph_enabled is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_image_id is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_image is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$open_graph_images is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$twitter_card is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_card is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_title is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_description is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_image is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_creator is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$twitter_site is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$estimated_reading_time_minutes is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$canonical is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$main_schema_id is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$site_url is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$schema_article_type is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$site_name is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$site_represents_reference is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$id is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$main_image_id is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$main_image_url is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$schema_page_type is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$title is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$has_image is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Context\Meta_Tags_Context::$description is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$breadcrumbs is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64

Deprecated: strtolower(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\generators\schema-generator.php on line 176

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Yoast\WP\SEO\Presentations\Indexable_Post_Type_Presentation::$schema is deprecated in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-content\plugins\wordpress-seo\src\presentations\abstract-presentation.php on line 64
Contact Marc Margulis
818-998-0092

Save Mart Supermarkets v. Orchard Supply Hardware


Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Deprecated: Using null as an array offset is deprecated, use an empty string instead in D:\WWWRoot\mammothadvisors.com\www\wp-includes\class-wp-block-type-registry.php on line 167

Breach of Contract; Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing; and Specific Performance

Save Mart Supermarkets v. Orchard Supply Hardware
Superior Court of the State of California, County of Fresno, Case No. 09CECG01020

Counsel for Defendant: Bernard P. Simons, Esq. of Reed Smith
Expert for Defandant: Marc S. Margulis, C.F.A., A.S.A., M.B.A

On September 4, 2007, Save Mart (Lessor) and Orchard Supply Hardware (OSH) (Lessee) executed a lease and construction rider for a 54,850 sq. ft. “to be built” building in an 88,275 sq. ft. “to be built” community shopping center planned to consist of four buildings on an 8.59 acre corner parcel in northwest Fresno, California. The term of the lease was 20 years at a fixed, annual, triple net rent. Rent was to begin after Lessor delivered to OSH the building and after all on/off site improvements were completed. A second major tenant was purported to be CVS but negotiations failed due to the economic climate. Save Mart was unable to find another pharmacy tenant or tenants for any of the other intended spaces in the proposed shopping center, aside from OSH.

At no time did OSH anticipate being the sole tenant; at all times, OSH intended to be one of multiple, economically interdependent tenants. The Lessor’s failure to identify and lease to other tenants denied OSH a material inducement in the execution of the lease and shifted substantial risks from the Lessor to OSH.

In November of 2008, Save Mart sends a proposed First Amendment to OSH which sought OSH’s approval to allow phased construction of the site due to the state of the economy, despite its subsequent contention that it did not need OSH’s approval to do so. Phased construction would violate, not just the intent of the lease agreement, but several of its provisions including i) the right to quiet enjoyment, ii) that the Center would be
operated and maintained in good condition and in a manner comparable to similar properties in Fresno, and iii) an explicit provision protecting the Tenant from activities by the Landlord that would limit Tenant’s access, impede traffic, or impede the flow of Tenant’s customers to and from the premises. Simply, OSH contended that the lease neither contemplated nor allowed phased construction.

In February of 2009, OSH responds in good faith to Save Mart’s proposed First Amendment indicating its willingness to agree to phasing in return for nominal rent concessions as consideration for a valuable concession. Save Mart declined OSH’s proposal and declined to negotiate. Save Mart commences grading on March 16, 2009 but does not pull permits which had been approved and available on December 19, 2008.
OSH informs Save Mart on March 18 that it intends to exercise its right to termination followed by its notice of termination.

As of the date of trial in March of 2011, neither the OSH building nor any other portion of the shopping center had been built. As of the trial date, Save Mart had found no tenant to replace OSH or tenants for any of the other planned buildings for its proposed shopping center.

Marc S. Margulis of Mammoth Advisors, Inc. was retained as the damages expert on behalf of Defendant, OSH to i) analyze and rebut, as appropriate, the analysis and opinion of Plaintiff’s damages expert and ii) determine Save Mart’s damages independently under a presumption of OSH’s liability. Mr. Margulis’ independent analysis confirmed the testimony of one of Plaintiff’s experts and another of Defendant’s experts that the OSH lease could be replaced with one with comparable economic value to the Plaintiff within 5 years. He, then, calculated alleged damages recoverable under California Civil Code Sec. 1951.2 and determined, consistent with benefit-of-the-bargain theory, that offsetting lost rents was the opportunity value, or earning power, of the more than $10,000,000 of on-site, off-site and building costs avoided by Save Mart until such
time as the current harsh economic climate improves and a tenant is found to replace OSH. Mr. Margulis testified at trial in Fresno, the home of Save Mart’s headquarters. A motion by Plaintiff’s counsel to exclude only that portion of Mr. Margulis’ testimony pertaining to offsets was sustained.

The jury found in favor of the Plaintiff. Subsequent motions were denied. An appeal was filed, but was settled on terms favorable to OSH.